Fare Guide

Estimated lowest fares found within 7 days

Cheapest Airline American Airlines

The cheapest airline(s) flying from New York City to St Thomas Island is American Airlines.

  • American Airlines American Airlines
  • Spirit Airlines Spirit Airlines
  • JetBlue Airways JetBlue Airways
  • United Airlines United Airlines
Cheapest Month April

Travel Period: February 2025 - January 2026

The cheapest month(s) to fly from New York City to St Thomas Island is April.

  • Feb 2025
  • Mar 2025
  • Apr 2025
  • May 2025
  • Jun 2025
  • Jul 2025
  • Aug 2025
  • Sep 2025
  • Oct 2025
  • Nov 2025
  • Dec 2025
  • Jan 2026
Cheapest Day of the Week Monday

The cheapest day(s) of the week to fly from New York City to St Thomas Island is Monday.

  • Sun Sunday
  • Mon Monday
  • Tue Tuesday
  • Wed Wednesday
  • Thu Thursday
  • Fri Friday
  • Sat Saturday

Flight Schedules

Last Updated: Thu, 2 Jan, 2025

  • Time Earliest
    • Earliest
    • Latest
  • Depart Earliest
    • Earliest
    • Latest
  • Arrive
    • Earliest
    • Latest
  • Duration
    • Shortest
    • Longest
  • Stopover
    All
  • Airline Filter by Airline
    View All Airline
  • Availability
    • M
    • T
    • W
    • T
    • F
    • S
    • S
  • 07:00 EWR
    12:00 STT
    4Hrs, 00m Direct
  • EWRNewark Liberty International Airport 07:00 - STT 12:00 4h Direct
  • EWRNewark Liberty International Airport 07:00
  • STTSt Thomas Cyril E King Airport 12:00
  • 4h
  • Direct
  • United Airlines (UA 1529)Boeing 737 Max 8 Passenger
  • United Airlines (UA 1529)
    • M
    • T
    • W
    • T
    • F
    • S
    • S
  • Boeing 737 Max 8 Passenger
  • 07:55 EWR
    17:30 STT
    8Hrs, 35m 1 Stop (SJU)
  • EWRNewark Liberty International Airport 07:55 - STT 17:30 8h 35m 1 Stop (SJU) San Juan
  • EWRNewark Liberty International Airport 07:55
    SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 16:55
  • SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 12:47
    STTSt Thomas Cyril E King Airport 17:30
  • 8h 35m (4h 08m)
  • 1 Stop SJU · San Juan 4h 08m
  • United Airlines (UA 2143)Boeing 767 400
    Silver Airways (3M 130)Aerospatiale Alenia Atr 42
  • United Airlines (UA 2143)
    • M
    • T
    • W
    • T
    • F
    • S
    • -
  • 08:00 JFK
    14:35 STT
    5Hrs, 35m 1 Stop (SJU)
  • JFKNew York John F. Kennedy International Airport 08:00 - STT 14:35 5h 35m 1 Stop (SJU) San Juan
  • JFKNew York John F. Kennedy International Airport 08:00
    SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 14:00
  • SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 12:52
    STTSt Thomas Cyril E King Airport 14:35
  • 5h 35m (1h 08m)
  • 1 Stop SJU · San Juan 1h 08m
  • JetBlue Airways (B6 503)Airbus Industrie A321
    Cape Air (9K 8291)Cessna
  • JetBlue Airways (B6 503)
    • -
    • -
    • -
    • T
    • F
    • -
    • S
  • 08:00 JFK
    14:40 STT
    5Hrs, 40m 1 Stop (SJU)
  • JFKNew York John F. Kennedy International Airport 08:00 - STT 14:40 5h 40m 1 Stop (SJU) San Juan
  • JFKNew York John F. Kennedy International Airport 08:00
    SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 14:05
  • SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 12:52
    STTSt Thomas Cyril E King Airport 14:40
  • 5h 40m (1h 13m)
  • 1 Stop SJU · San Juan 1h 13m
  • JetBlue Airways (B6 503)Airbus Industrie A321
    Silver Airways (3M 116)Aerospatiale Alenia Atr 42
  • JetBlue Airways (B6 503)
    • -
    • -
    • -
    • -
    • -
    • -
    • S
  • 08:00 JFK
    14:50 STT
    5Hrs, 50m 1 Stop (SJU)
  • JFKNew York John F. Kennedy International Airport 08:00 - STT 14:50 5h 50m 1 Stop (SJU) San Juan
  • JFKNew York John F. Kennedy International Airport 08:00
    SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 14:15
  • SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 12:52
    STTSt Thomas Cyril E King Airport 14:50
  • 5h 50m (1h 23m)
  • 1 Stop SJU · San Juan 1h 23m
  • JetBlue Airways (B6 503)Airbus Industrie A321
    Cape Air (9K 8011)Cessna
  • JetBlue Airways (B6 503)
    • M
    • -
    • -
    • -
    • -
    • -
    • -
  • 09:47 EWR
    17:20 STT
    6Hrs, 33m 1 Stop (SJU)
  • EWRNewark Liberty International Airport 09:47 - STT 17:20 6h 33m 1 Stop (SJU) San Juan
  • EWRNewark Liberty International Airport 09:47
    SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 16:45
  • SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 14:40
    STTSt Thomas Cyril E King Airport 17:20
  • 6h 33m (2h 05m)
  • 1 Stop SJU · San Juan 2h 05m
  • United Airlines (UA 1556)Boeing 737 Max 9 Passenger
    Cape Air (9K 8071)Cessna
  • United Airlines (UA 1556)
    • M
    • T
    • W
    • T
    • F
    • S
    • S
  • 09:47 EWR
    17:30 STT
    6Hrs, 43m 1 Stop (SJU)
  • EWRNewark Liberty International Airport 09:47 - STT 17:30 6h 43m 1 Stop (SJU) San Juan
  • EWRNewark Liberty International Airport 09:47
    SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 16:55
  • SJUSan Juan Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport 14:40
    STTSt Thomas Cyril E King Airport 17:30
  • 6h 43m (2h 15m)
  • 1 Stop SJU · San Juan 2h 15m
  • United Airlines (UA 1556)Boeing 737 Max 9 Passenger
    Silver Airways (3M 130)Aerospatiale Alenia Atr 42
  • United Airlines (UA 1556)
    • M
    • T
    • W
    • T
    • F
    • S
    • S
No Schedules Sorry, there are no schedules matching your filters. Try removing one. reset
What’s the fastest flight time from New York City to St Thomas Island?

The fastest flight time for direct flights from New York City to St Thomas Island is 4 hours . Check latest flight schedules & prices on Wego.

How far is St Thomas Island from New York City?

The flight distance between New York City and St Thomas Island is 2636km. Check all available flights on Wego.

When is the earliest and latest flight of the day?

The earliest flight of the day departs at 07:00. The last flight of the day departs at 07:00. See the full list of flight times on Wego.

How many airlines offer direct flights from New York City to St Thomas Island?

There are 1 airlines that offer direct flights from New York City to St Thomas Island. Find out the list of airlines on Wego.